Guest Reviews | Enology Wine Bar & Bistro, Saint James NY
Kind Words

From Our Guests

Every review below is a verified Google review, published as written, with last names shortened to a first name and initial.

4.84 out of 5from 58 Google reviews

  • Service was incredible. Everyone was so kind, attentive, and very knowledgeable. Every dish was excellent, truly no notes. I had the Nirvana Blush cocktail and that was also delightful. The atmosphere is simultaneously cozy and sophisticated, making for a great date night spot. My group had the olives, fish tacos, octopus, crab cakes, whipped ricotta, tuna tartare, and one of each dessert, and every single one of them was spectacular. I am just out here visiting family but even on this trip I plan to come back at least once more. I live in Arizona and the fish tacos were genuinely some of the best I have ever had. Also their music taste is wonderful.
    Julia F.August 2026
  • Pleasant dinner and drinks , wine suggestions were great . I will visit again .
    Jose D.August 2026
  • We had an outstanding experience from start to finish. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely welcoming, and every dish was beautifully presented and full of flavor. Delicious! The wine and cocktail selections were thoughtfully chosen and elevated an already outstanding dining experience. You can tell the owner and team take great pride in every detail.
    Chris I.July 2026
  • If you love wine, this is the spot on the North Shore. The Cellar List is huge but the team makes it easy, and they actually listen to what you like before recommending something. We did a few small plates and the beef tartare was a standout. Great pace, no rush, just a really nice evening out in Saint James.
    Sweet S.July 2026
  • Had brunch here with the family on Sunday. There was live music (quite good too!), delicious food, and excellent service. Shout out to Samantha and Jimmy! We will be back for their dinner menu!
    Dental O.June 2026
  • From the moment you walk in you feel extremely comfortable. The friendliness and professionalism of all staff members was top notch. The drinks were excellent! All the food we ordered was just delicious
    Doreen V.June 2026
  • Incredible food and even more incredible service. Highly recommend, will be back
    Anna B.June 2026
  • Absolutely loved this restaurant. The atmosphere was elegant and versatile — perfect for a girls night, date night, or even a family dinner. The staff were incredibly warm, welcoming, and attentive from start to finish. The food was amazing. The jerk chicken had the perfect amount of spice, and the meat was so tender and flavorful. The lamb was definitely my favorite — cooked to perfection and absolutely delicious. The steak was really good too. Everything we ordered was delicious and beautifully prepared. I’ll definitely be back!
    Tat (.May 2026
  • Wonderful dinner and excellent service. Will be back!
    Simone S.May 2026
  • This wine bar is a great find. The service is excellent—attentive, friendly, and genuinely welcoming. The food is delicious and well-priced, making it a great value for a night out. Jimmy, the owner, is especially kind and makes you feel right at home, which really adds to the overall experience. Susie, Samantha, and Gunther were helpful and kind. It does get a bit noisy. Overall, a fantastic spot for good wine, great food, and warm hospitality. We will definitely be back! Update: We returned a week later and the experience was just as good. They have new Spring menu and the food is delicious. Already have reservations for later this month.
    Ellen B.April 2026
  • BRAVO!!!! We went to Enology for the first time on Friday and everything was absolutely incredible! First and foremost the staff are all wonderful! The hostess (blonde girl) was so kind and welcoming. Our server Sebastian was awesome and so accommodating and kind. The drinks, the food EVERYTHING was 100%! We ordered the wings, octopus, steak, fries, salad whipped ricotta and I couldn’t pick a favorite if you made me, everything was so delicious. Jimmy we wish you and your team the best of luck and are so happy we live around the block! We will be back quite often!!! Thank you for an amazing experience and opening a beautiful space for Saint James!!!
    James K.April 2026
  • First time at the restaurant and won’t be the last!From the owner coming over and introducing himself and welcoming us in to our bartender who was on top of her game( sorry missed her name)very cool vibe- sat at the bar this trip will hit a table next!looking around seemed everyone one else were enjoying themselves to! Food and drink Excellent!
    Chris R.March 2026
  • Highly recommend! Food was phenomenal, 10/10. Service was excellent, especially Sam & Susan! The atmosphere was very welcoming & a lot of fun! Will definitely be back
    Becky D.March 2026
  • From the moment we walked in, the team made us feel genuinely welcome and special. Our server was incredibly knowledgeable, sharing thoughtful wine suggestions tailored just to what we like without any pressure. Owner Jimmy stopped by to chat and check in, which added such a warm, personal touch. Everything felt attentive yet relaxed – never rushed, always spot-on. It's the kind of hospitality that turns a nice evening into something truly memorable. Can't wait to go back and soak it up again!
    JIbber I.March 2026
  • What truly sets Enology Wine Bar & Bistro apart is the service. From the moment you walk in, the staff makes you feel like an invited guest in their own home rather than just a customer. The team here doesn’t just "serve" wine; they are true flavor guides. They have an incredible knack for recommending the perfect glass based on your mood or palate, and they do it with zero pretension. Whether you’re a total novice or a seasoned sommelier, they meet you where you are with genuine passion and deep knowledge of every bottle on the list. It’s rare to find a spot that balances high-end expertise with such warm, Greek-influenced hospitality. If you want a night out where you feel genuinely looked after, this is the place. Huge shoutout to the staff for making every visit feel like a special occasion!
    Xpresso H.March 2026
  • Beautiful spot !!! The wine list is very well curated. Bartender seemd a little frazzled and not knowledgeable enough about the wines by the glass. The little carafe pouring is not classy for a place like that.I get the portion control but there can be other ways to do. Server introducing herself and saying "i will be taking care of you tonight is not needed in. a classy place like that (especially if you're the only one serving). Presentation of the dips can be better.Overall, a great spot and i am sure in time they will only get better!!!! Prices should be higher.
    RSFebruary 2026
  • Had a great date night at enology last night! Got a spot at the bar when they first opened and the bartenders were so friendly. The sommelier picked out great wines for us to try and the food was incredible!! Atmosphere is perfect for date night or girls night out. Owner is super friendly as well! Lovely to meet him. Don’t skip on the chocolate chip cookie for dessert
    Adina J.February 2026
  • All the plates, drinks, and desserts were delicious. I would highly recommend the short rib flatbread. To top it all off, the owner / manager came up to us and asked various meaningful questions regarding our experience. Great service, dining, and atmosphere. Will be back.
    Grim O.February 2026
  • Ok so I give lots of reviews for lots of places. It can be difficult to do 5 stars across the board but this one I am happy to do. Ill start with the wine. I am not a guy who prefer merlots and cabernet savigions I like the off varietals. Here the owner Jim recommend a fantastic cabernet franc, we had an outstanding Champalou Vouvray, (Chenin Blanc) Syrahs Zinfindels ugh so good. The food, the short rib flatbread, sooo good, gambas shrimp, the whipped ricotta unbelievable. And then on top of that, the great service and atmosphere, they were running a comedy show with an... amazing, hysterical line up. I mean each one was better than the next. To say ill be back isnt enough, ill likely be the guy they have to force to leave at the end of the night. NO BS, we had an outstanding time tonight. Outstanding!
    Brian P.February 2026
  • First time coming here and it exceeded expectations. The food was fantastic. The whipped ricotta was delicious and the arancini was my favorite dish. Great wine selection. Very friendly staff. Definitely coming back.
    Michael T.February 2026
  • This place is amazing. The food was great, the service was attentive but not pushy. Food came out fast and the perfect temperature. We ordered a ton and loved it all. Octopus, cookie, and dips were stand outs. Great wine recommendation too! The atmosphere is dark and moody - perfect date night.
    Olivia K.January 2026
  • Absolutely wonderful! Food was superb, chef expertly prepared with flavors and ingredients that were exceptional. Octopus was phenomenal. Wine and cocktails are perfectly served and waitstaff are attentive and knowledgeable. Jimmy the owner is very attentive . Bravo!!
    Jannine R.January 2026
  • I never leave reviews, but this place just gets it. Best food, wine, and cocktails I’ve had on Long Island. The chef is dialed in, the staff is genuinely happy, and Caroline crushed it. 20/10.
    Javier S.January 2026
  • Incredible wine selection and awesome staff and ownership. Such a welcome addition to St. James.
    Adam S.January 2026
  • We had a fabulous time at enology. We went to celebrate an engagement originally thinking we would only get drinks however they were very knowledgeable about how to make options on their menu vegan. They celebrated with us for our engagement! They made it a very personal experience. We are from NH and it will be a stop we go to every time we go to LI. The owner even stopped by to check on us. A must visit in our minds!
    Veronica H.January 2026
  • Enology is an absolute gem. The food is outstanding—beautifully prepared, full of flavor, and clearly made with care. What truly sets this wine bar apart, though, is the incredible wine selection. There’s a wide variety to choose from, whether you’re a seasoned wine lover or just looking to try something new, and the staff is knowledgeable and happy to guide you. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a relaxed evening or a special night out. Enology will not disappoint.
    Vanesza R.January 2026
  • My family and I went here to try something different and had a wonderful experience! All of the staff, especially our server, Susan, were very kind, attentive, and accommodating to our needs. Susan gave great food and wine recommendations that we all enjoyed and paired well. Will be back again for sure!
    Andrew M.January 2026
  • Our first visit to this wonderful addition to the Smithtown / St James area, atmosphere is fantastic, great vibe , food , wine and wait staff !! Really enjoyed the hospitality and looking forward to many more visits. Congrats to our Dr. K for knocking it out of the park !!
    Matt M.January 2026
  • This is an upscale experience without the pretense. Cozy , warm, friendly. The food is familiar( ribs, burger, steak) yet unexpected in flavor combinations! In the best possible way. The steak is served with French fries! Who doesn’t want French fries with their meal!?! The wait staff is super knowledgeable about the wines served and happy to help you pick the perfect one! Super helpful for someone like me who isn’t knowledgeable about wine! It’s elegant in execution yet friendly and comfortable. It’s where you want to go to spend an evening catching up with friends or enjoying time with family. It’s an entire experience not to be missed.
    Stacy N.January 2026
  • Delicious drinks, good food and wonderful service. A very elegant and classy atmosphere as well.
    J J.January 2026
  • This wine bar is an absolute gem! The food is delicious, the wine selection is thoughtfully curated, and there’s truly something for every palate. What really made the experience stand out was Keith & Josh the bartenders arefriendly, knowledgeable, and passionate about what they do. Their recommendations were spot-on and made the night even more enjoyable. Great atmosphere, great service, and outstanding food and wine. Can’t wait to come back! 🍷
    Elegant R.January 2026
  • The food is seriously good - everything we had tasted amazing. Highly recommend trying the octopus, it’s super tender and tomato jam is absolutely outstanding. Besides that, great atmosphere, relaxed vibe, and a solid wine list. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in the area.
    A A.December 2025
  • Last night was a great experience..the staff was amazing. Great atmosphere and ambiance. Honestly this is exactly what Saint James needed. I pray for success and I will definitely be back soon. Job well done.
    Christopher P.December 2025
  • We've been excited to try Enology since they announced their opening. We made a reservation to be safe for a Friday evening and did not feel rushed at all. The atmosphere was elegant and welcoming. It only got a little loud by the end of the night, but not so much that we couldn't hear each other. The service was professional, friendly, knowledgeable, and present without interrupting. Our waitress Lay was very helpful and even offered to pair our selected tapas with recommended wine tastings when we told her we weren't sure what to order. Definitely trust her to guide your meal! The owner also stopped by a few times to check in and make sure we were happy with everything, and the kitchen staff bringing our the meals were happy and friendly. Food: the group of us tried basically half the menu and every item was delicious. The bread with olive oil, brown sugar butter, and garlic butter was fresh and warm. The Caesar salad was just enough to split and had a unique flavor and texture. The whipped ricotta with honey was a must have! The eggplant dish was unique and had both crispy and savory pieces. The arancini in vodka sauce had a hint of spice and a nice outer crisp. The garlic shrimp was another must have! We kept the leftover oil and ordered extra bread to dip until the plate was clean. Next we had the octopus which had roasted potatoes and a delicious, sweet sauce. The cauliflower entree was an entire head and had a nice sauce to dip. The chicken katsu was perfectly crispy and the sauces were delicious. The flatbread was delicious, too. Even the side of fries which looked plain had a garlicky flavor to them and were great for dipping in the leftover garlic shrimp oil. The desserts tasted even better than they looked on the menu! Every item's presentation was thoughtful and obviously made with love. Drinks: we tried a few specialty cocktails and none disappointed. All of the wine tastings our server Lay suggested paired beautifully with the food, and the pairings made me appreciate the differences in the wine more. She even labeled the tastings by name and food pairing so we could enjoy without thinking. We will definitely be back and recommend this place to our friends and family!
    Stephen G.December 2025
  • Gorgeous restaurant with 5 star service. Our server Lay was attentive and timed plating perfectly. Jimmy stopped by often to offer menu thoughts. Let me not forget that our meal was OUTSTANDING!
    kim S.December 2025
  • Finally a wine bar worthy of its name. Great selection of wine served at the right temperature. Knowledgeable and experienced staff. Delicious food. Overall wonderful night in a beautiful setting.
    Lucy A.December 2025
  • Such a great night with girlfriends. This is what our town needs!! Such a friendly environment. The owner came over to the table, more than once to make sure that we were all happy. The food was delicious. We just ordered some tapas plates, but you can also order a meal. Drinks were good. Wine was delicious. This place is a win-win!!! Can’t wait to go back
    Alyson C.December 2025
  • What a great place to have dinner with some great wine. Very wine knowledgeable. Waite staff and bartenders were excellent and very personable. The atmosphere was special in being romantic but yet relaxing and chic.
    Joe G.December 2025
  • Came with my wife for a date night. Food was great, wine and service was amazing. Very knowledgeable on there wine and every option was a great choice. Highly reccomend!
    Paul M.December 2025
  • An exceptional addition to St James. Enology Wine Bar is just what the “dentist” ordered. An inspired vision brought to life with thoughtful intentionality that can be felt thoughtful the entire experience: food & wine pairing, ambiance & vibe.
    Rich C.December 2025
  • What a great gem! We made a reservation at Enology looking for a great time and it sure did deliver. The servers were attentive and we were always checked on by the owner, Jimmy, and his great team. If you’re not sure what wine to have, the amazing team will guide you in the right direction and deliver an amazing pairing to the menu. All the food was fresh, innovative and delicious. Highly recommend!
    Viet T.November 2025
  • The atmosphere was absolutely perfect! Food and drinks were even better! Zucchini flatbread & the pasta is a MUST try, you will not regret it!
    Francesca A.November 2025
  • Amazing cozy and elegant place. Wine is so good and food delicious. LINDSEY was me server and I loved her vey kind, her recommendations were the best. Loved, loved this place.
    Josselyn V.November 2025
  • WOW! Did I just step into a wine bar in Manhattan? Gorgeous atmosphere great cocktails and the menu is very diverse. There’s something for everyone and everything we tried was delicious. Will be going back, not soon enough though, waiting for the grand opening!
    Julie M.November 2025

The rating above covers all 58 Google reviews the restaurant has received, not only the ones shown here. Read them all on Google